Cyber-Bullying on Salem

Forum for off topic and general discussion.

Re: Cyber-Bullying on Salem

Postby Nixman » Sun Dec 16, 2012 4:09 pm

Naruchico wrote:
Nixman wrote:Cyber bullying refers to abuse towards people, not towards virtual avatars. I think you are a bit confused about the nature of bullying and how damaging it can be, but to use it as an attempt to seek attention for something you have complete control over, even so far as to bolden your words and increase the size is a clear example.

People have already given you suggestions on how you can avoid this kind of situation but its clear your not interested in a solution you just want this childish behaviour to spill into the help forums, which quite frankly is a place where new players come, the last thing they need to see is this immature behaviour.


Yes abuse towards people, I do understand that, I can put an example forward, say I was a youtuber or livestreamer, salem being my primary game and my source of income, every time I try to make a video or stream even though I have hidden all signs of my area, they constantly seek my place, destroy anything I make, and overall prevent me from doing my job, this is effecting my life, not just my in-game character.

And again I see the solutions for me as a player, and yes those can work, for a while. What I am asking is for a member of Paradox or Seatribe to give me an idea of what they personally planned to do to prevent this kind of harassment towards players, or will they simply always look the other way, even though:

A: it may effect their income (new player joins spends $5, large super group sits outside town kills player takes money, player quits, player was a game reviewer THE END)
B: the size of the player base
C: The enjoyment of the base of players over the elite players
D: The quality of a new players experience
E: The overall appearance of the game itself(a perfect reviewers example "The game itself is run by a small group of players who hold the game hostage from the new players")

I love salem itself I just don't want the game to get destroyed by a lack of control that super-solidifies the veterans and banishes the new players, leaving nothing but an elitist group of players.


I don't see how Salem can fall into a category of cyber bullying or how Seatribe/Paradox can be held liable, as MagicmanITC explained, this is a virtual hostile environment, the webpage now has a mature content warning, everything is in place to ensure players are aware of what kind of game this is, it is highly advertised that there is perma-death and that the game is PvP focused. Its like stepping into a pit of snakes and then complaining you have been bitten.

Laying this on Seatribe or Paradox's is unreasonable. There are professionals within social services and many other avenues of help available for bullying which funnily enough do not have involvement within the gaming industry for a clear and obvious reason, games by nature are competitive and require direct action by all involved to participate, they also have many options for self-removal and/or prevention methods.

Cyber bullying is a serious problem, in my profession we deal with all kinds of serious abuse and there are clear definitions as to what constitutes bullying in all its forms. In many cases the bullies will claim they are being bullied, and they generally shout louder than the others. In almost all cases, direct affliction upon a persons real life or identity is required because at that point the person under this kind of abuse will have no choices, that is when the problem becomes serious.

Using the term cyber bullying to bring attention to a personal dispute that clearly is not 'no choice' bullying, is worse than what the bullies do, taking and using the term for personal benefit detracts from the real problems people have to deal with and how serious that can become.

IMO there is nothing for Seatribe or Paradox to say on the matter other than speak to someone you trust IRL.
Last edited by Nixman on Sun Dec 16, 2012 4:10 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Nixman
 
Posts: 168
Joined: Thu Nov 08, 2012 1:36 pm

Re: Cyber-Bullying on Salem

Postby harflimon » Sun Dec 16, 2012 4:09 pm

People getting spammed in Boston with abusive speech might be a problem (I don't know it's never happened to me, but maybe I'm the exception). I assume at some point there needs to be a function to block chat from someone. That's really the only thing that needs to be done. But I don't think that's what OP is getting at, I think he just means new players getting griefed by the Tribe. That's not bullying, that's playing the game. At no point should player behavior outside of chat be controlled in any manner. Would completely destroy the dynamic of this game. If that means giving up on a larger playerbase I think the devs are willing to do that, because otherwise they would lose their core playerbase.

Edit: Wow, this is just some Beau-esqe *****. OP has lived up to his reputation once again.
User avatar
harflimon
 
Posts: 150
Joined: Mon Oct 01, 2012 1:21 pm

Re: Cyber-Bullying on Salem

Postby Naruchico » Sun Dec 16, 2012 4:41 pm

I definitely mean new players (and what reputation, I have like 10 post?)

Cyberbullying is the use of the Internet and related technologies to harm other people, in a deliberate, repeated, and hostile manner.

I can imagine for most people this won't happen, but for some, as I said a youtube, livestreamers, hell the forums. Someone gets your email, spams all your posts, constantly attacks you on IRC, or even maybe you channel. It can happen.

I wasn't getting on here to say look at me, and what I felt was a small case, I was saying are there anything coming to the game to make sure it doesn't turn into something worse. The game itself is a hostile environment, I know that, but my concern is that it becomes so much common-place that it is brought outside the game environment.

A perfect example is the amount of post of people who have a bad moment in-game, come to the forums to let off steam, and simply get bashed for being aggravated, then they go to the IRC just wanting to talk to other people about the game and get back in with refreshed vigor, only to get the same people bashing them again, and with a small community how can you avoid the people that will intentionally make sure you can only progress with as little help as possible in a community based game.

I'll give a small example of my concerns.

Bob has a small village, the big guys trash his village, he goes the forum "dang it my village is trashed...now what do I do!?"
Replies: "quit whining, shut up, change servers, stop playing, get over it" (bob feels:thanks for the constructive help)
IRC: Bob: "Hey guys, I need help getting started again I got trashed"
Replies: -same forum guys- "oh god the newb is here to beg for help, boo hoo cry baby wah wah help me! go away newb!"

I know not everyone is like this but this could definitely happen, and I do see quite a bit of posts generally ending like this.

Paradox and Sea-tribe can't do much about this of course, but if the game encourages this behavior it can spread out from it, I guess what I would say on the topic is, why can't helping other players be more rewarding than simply looting, plundering and pillaging while trolling newbs?
Naruchico
 
Posts: 9
Joined: Fri Nov 23, 2012 3:24 am

Re: Cyber-Bullying on Salem

Postby Procne » Sun Dec 16, 2012 4:51 pm

Naruchico wrote:I definitely mean new players (and what reputation, I have like 10 post?)

Cyberbullying is the use of the Internet and related technologies to harm other people, in a deliberate, repeated, and hostile manner.
Are you hurt? How?
I wasn't getting on here to say look at me, and what I felt was a small case, I was saying are there anything coming to the game to make sure it doesn't turn into something worse. The game itself is a hostile environment, I know that, but my concern is that it becomes so much common-place that it is brought outside the game environment.

If someone takes game issues outside the game then what are the devs supposed to do about that?
A perfect example is the amount of post of people who have a bad moment in-game, come to the forums to let off steam, and simply get bashed for being aggravated, then they go to the IRC just wanting to talk to other people about the game and get back in with refreshed vigor, only to get the same people bashing them again, and with a small community how can you avoid the people that will intentionally make sure you can only progress with as little help as possible in a community based game.

I'll give a small example of my concerns.

Bob has a small village, the big guys trash his village, he goes the forum "dang it my village is trashed...now what do I do!?"
Replies: "quit whining, shut up, change servers, stop playing, get over it" (bob feels:thanks for the constructive help)
IRC: Bob: "Hey guys, I need help getting started again I got trashed"
Replies: -same forum guys- "oh god the newb is here to beg for help, boo hoo cry baby wah wah help me! go away newb!"

I know not everyone is like this but this could definitely happen, and I do see quite a bit of posts generally ending like this.

What's the problem in that example? Ever heard of "reputation"?
Paradox and Sea-tribe can't do much about this of course, but if the game encourages this behavior it can spread out from it, I guess what I would say on the topic is, why can't helping other players be more rewarding than simply looting, plundering and pillaging while trolling newbs?

I guess because it's not in real-life. Any mechanic to promote it would be artificial.
Image
Procne
 
Posts: 3696
Joined: Mon Sep 03, 2012 11:34 pm

Re: Cyber-Bullying on Salem

Postby Yes » Sun Dec 16, 2012 5:08 pm

Naruchico wrote:say I was a youtuber or livestreamer, salem being my primary game and my source of income, every time I try to make a video or stream even though I have hidden all signs of my area, they constantly seek my place, destroy anything I make, and overall prevent me from doing my job, this is effecting my life, not just my in-game character.

Imagine: you are a livestreamer, youtuber, twitcher trying to make a living by showing how you play counter-strike. But you can't. Because you are constantly being killed by enemies. They blow up your ammunition boxes with c4, kill you with a knife to your head, once every week there is a "cheater" who spins like a spinning wheel, shoots with unlimited ammo and kills everyone on the whole map in 5 seconds.
So. People can't pay you money for you to study in your college because they don't like to see how a character in a game dies, they think it's pathetic and boring. They also don't click 10 times a day on the ads on your videos with disabled ad-block.
So. You start to cry, write on a note that you were bullied by enemy terrorists in Counter-Strike. Then you kill yourself.
That's just my thoughts, no tralling.
(a person who plays online games since the 1980s about salem) laywn wrote:I have never seen anything so down right dirty!
User avatar
Yes
 
Posts: 796
Joined: Sat Nov 10, 2012 9:53 pm

Re: Cyber-Bullying on Salem

Postby MagicManICT » Sun Dec 16, 2012 5:14 pm

Procne wrote:
Naruchico wrote:I wasn't getting on here to say look at me, and what I felt was a small case, I was saying are there anything coming to the game to make sure it doesn't turn into something worse. The game itself is a hostile environment, I know that, but my concern is that it becomes so much common-place that it is brought outside the game environment.

If someone takes game issues outside the game then what are the devs supposed to do about that?
.

The "devs" don't do anything. The publisher/manager of the community does, and that person can track any real threats made through any servers they own, decide if the threat is credible, and file it. If a player becomes a problem, they can be banned from forums and other forms of communication or from the game period. If the threats seem real and of an immediate danger to someone, law enforcement can be contacted. However, if someone just leaves the game, tracks down what they can find on the internet, and shows up at another player's door, then no, the devs nor publisher can do a thing. (In this day of people posting anything and everything to sites like Facebook, it's getting pretty easy to track down another player if I'm a raging killer.)

As far as trying to make a living off live-streaming a game like Salem... don't unless you want to go through a lot of hoops or have a special arrangement with management. The publicity might be worth the effort for the game publisher and dev, but for the journalist trying to publish their work and make some money, the headaches of dealing with asshattery is just too much. How are these actions any different than protesters making obscene gestures behind a tv news reporter?
I am a moderator. I moderate stuff. When I do, I write in this color.
JohnCarver wrote:anybody who argues to remove a mechanic that allows "yet another" way to summon somebody is really a carebear in disguise trying to save his own hide.
MagicManICT
 
Posts: 5088
Joined: Wed Aug 01, 2012 1:46 am

Re: Cyber-Bullying on Salem

Postby sabinati » Sun Dec 16, 2012 5:17 pm

Paradox/Seatribe please help me I'm being brutally cyberbullied in a PVP game
Admin for Salem Wiki • Make suggestions or complaints in the Wiki Suggestion thread
User avatar
sabinati
 
Posts: 1135
Joined: Wed Aug 01, 2012 1:48 am

Re: Cyber-Bullying on Salem

Postby MagicManICT » Sun Dec 16, 2012 5:21 pm

Naruchico, you have started what I consider to be a valuable thread with a valuable question, but don't dilute and derail your own thread with unrelated issues, namely the player attitudes in the game. I will be happy to lock this whole thing up until we have a reply from our overlords.
I am a moderator. I moderate stuff. When I do, I write in this color.
JohnCarver wrote:anybody who argues to remove a mechanic that allows "yet another" way to summon somebody is really a carebear in disguise trying to save his own hide.
MagicManICT
 
Posts: 5088
Joined: Wed Aug 01, 2012 1:46 am

Re: Cyber-Bullying on Salem

Postby Nixman » Sun Dec 16, 2012 5:25 pm

Naruchico wrote:Bob has a small village, the big guys trash his village, he goes the forum "dang it my village is trashed...now what do I do!?"
Replies: "quit whining, shut up, change servers, stop playing, get over it" (bob feels:thanks for the constructive help)
IRC: Bob: "Hey guys, I need help getting started again I got trashed"
Replies: -same forum guys- "oh god the newb is here to beg for help, boo hoo cry baby wah wah help me! go away newb!"


You dont seem to understand

By your own definition:

Virtual Bob decides to play a game where other players can trash villages
Virtual Bobs village gets trashed
Virtual bob decides to go into an IRC channel
Virtual Bob gets typical internet hostility

Something else is important, Virtual. Bullying refer to attacks on a real identifiable person, Virtual Bob is not a real identifiable person but a virtual avatar being directly controlled by an anonymous person.

If you had a profile on youtube that identified yourself and you were being directly bullied or harrassed 'outside the nature of the game/environment', then yes I would agree that you were being bullied, but that is not the case in Salem, and obviously due to your motives in this thread, is certainly not the case here.
Nixman
 
Posts: 168
Joined: Thu Nov 08, 2012 1:36 pm

Re: Cyber-Bullying on Salem

Postby Naruchico » Sun Dec 16, 2012 5:29 pm

MagicManICT wrote:Naruchico, you have started what I consider to be a valuable thread with a valuable question, but don't dilute and derail your own thread with unrelated issues, namely the player attitudes in the game. I will be happy to lock this whole thing up until we have a reply from our overlords.



I'm not going to dilute or derail any further, I will just wait to hear what they have to say, and I hope no one else causes anyone more trouble in this post.

Thank you, MagicManICT
Naruchico
 
Posts: 9
Joined: Fri Nov 23, 2012 3:24 am

PreviousNext

Return to City upon a Hill

Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 9 guests