First Kill:
Over a year ago, someone that I thought was a noob moved in nearby. I tried to invite him to my village but he declined saying that he didn't want to so I said that's fine. Being the kind overlord I am, I offered to help him build a brick wall to keep bad people away. He said no he could build one himself if he wanted to.
Fast forwarding a few weeks I went back and checked on him to see that he had expanded his claim, but still had no defenses at all (Not even a crappy branch wall). I took my first fighter/murder alt over to his place and engaged him in combat, trying to teach him a lesson about how others wont simply walk away. Another few days I walked back over to his place and attempted again to help him put some defenses up, but again he refused. I left him some coal and enough mats to make a torchpost and a brazier.
I left him be for another 2 weeks before I checked back up on him. Still no defenses except a brazier and a torchpost undefended. The torchpost was off his claim so I took my fighter/murder alt over there and destroyed it and promptly put a few buckets of water on his brazier. Since I had his main kinned on my main at the time, I logged my fighter off a screen tile away from his house and waited. He logged on and the subsequent chase started. He had enough prof to build a brick wall, and around 200 blood. Didn't fight back against my 100 bile fighter and eventually succumbed.
I still keep his scalp in one of my chests, and his skeleton as well.


I honestly still feel bad, but taking into account that his characters wasn't that of a noobs, its better that he died when he did versus waiting until someone else did it. If you're still out there, Gratisbeliage, you're welcome.