Spazzmaticus wrote:I think what Magic is saying isn't that the issue is one-sided. He's just saying that a conspiracy theory is not the flip side of a generally accepted theory. In the realm of reason we don't use the word "theory" as frivolously as you might think. It doesn't mean that you just "guess" about anything and then shift the burden of proof unto the people that are sceptical to your case.
1. Issues don't usually have 2 sides, so there is rarely one side and the "flip side." Most social, political, and even scientific issues have many possible sides. Maybe a better phrase would be the "odd side of the dodecahedron?"
2. Theory has a very specific meaning. As Spazzmaticus says, the appropriate word would be "hypothesis," and even then that would imply that you're taking the facts and applying some level of logic to them. In cases of conspiracy theories, you can't even call it a hypothesis. then again, when I was in school, one of my friends popped off "It's just a theory, it could be wrong" one day, and the saying became our thing any time someone was randomly guessing.
3. The burden of proof is always on the one presenting a theory. This is why the US and most other industrialized nations have moved to a innocent until proven guilty. A prosecutor's thoughts and ideas of what happened are just a theory of what the truth is based on the facts available. If you presume that a theory is correct without analyzing it, one can be lead to believe anything. However, by presuming that a theory may or may not be correct, but not necessarily wrong (and can be revised), we become more intelligent overall and can find deeper and deeper truths.
I'm not saying that anything that comes from the "metaphysical" school of thought is outright wrong. I studied it for a very long time. Many things, such as many Eastern medicine practices, have, through research, proven to be good ideas. Other things, such as magic spells, have, so far, proven to be nothing more than pure fantasy. A person just needs to take a good analytical look at
everything they read, even those sources that are supposed to be highly reputable.