Salem

How exactly do the stockades work? I went to the judge with evidence and requested judgment. He took 500 silver but the criminal did not show up in the stockades for me to whip or throw tomatoes at.

Also I tracked a claim on evidence an the pointer pointed at the ocean when tracking in providence. Is their an island out in the ocean?

You must use the judged scent on a stockade.

Yes i m pretty sure i remember a while back JC saying something about an island off shore they made for players to fight over and that he would like more of this in the future, I could be wrong but if I'm not I'm pretty sure there's only one of these islands and i'd image its common knowledge who owns it so find that out and you'll know exactly who the criminal was.