Why the dumbing down of the humour symbols (Heart, star, lightning, whirlwind)? This feels taken out of nowhere. Colour + mouseover text should be enough to tell which humour is which. I agree the alchemical symbols are not familiar enough (for me) to make any quick association, but I think it is thematically cool to have them there.
Other that that minor quibble, I think this looks very good!
If I had to choose, I'd say I like the second screenshot from the bottom the best.
Also wondering like Potjeh whether those minimaps are mockups or actually procedurally generated?
EDIT: I also don't like the "Kongregate-cute" font in screenshot number one

(not counting the ancient and current screens)
I would post some pictures to show what I mean, but I am lazy.
Enough from this peanut for now.