Sounds like a lot upset people in here. Here's my take:
1. If you brought your main to the town that was a very poor choice.
2. There were a lot of issues being caused by the town folk. Everyone was calling each other spies - I warned this would only lead to trouble. There was tons of free loading going on. Only a few actually put time in building projects or anything.
Am I surprised Darwoth killed everyone? No, not at all. This is why I created an alt and I waited to see if the town was thriving after a while. When I saw no one was dead I started working on my alt there. Looks like I should of waited about a week or two longer - I only lost a few hours of time invested on him. So no biggie.
I don't think Darwoth should of killed everyone because my concern is it may have a negative impact on Jamestown population. I understand it was the easy solution, cut your losses and pull out your resources. But for all I know everyone who got killed could now be super motivated to build up characters for revenge.
Either way everyone was warned multiple times by people in the thread of the foreseeable outcome. It's a shame the Town didn't turn out, there was huge potential for growth but a baby sitter was needed.
Darwoth I had fun while it lasted, I'm interested in seeing the other issues/ongoings with the Town. Hopefully we'll see the episode on your site or a more in depth story of the on goings on the forums.
Carg.