good witch

[trungdle]

Next time on full metal alchemist......
Why do you need a counter to witchs when a majority of people don't even know what they do.

More dynamic? Alchemy is awesome and with our theme it fits well. They don't even need to counter the witch, they can just simply be better at knowing what witches do through studies.
Hell we can just do without the counter part. The plague doctors are into alchemy too, and many rendered version of alchemist involve plague and witches, which we have already.

I just don't understand the whole Alchemist vs Witch thing. It doesn't make sense.

Witches are misterious creature and alchemists are curious folks. They may be related that way.

[lachlaan]

Yeah wasn't really a legit suggestion. I suppose ye olden day witch hunters were just normal people with a desire to stabbify chicks that scorned them, which we already have ingame. As for counters to witches, I suppose learning what precautions to take and taking them is as good as it gets, and you can just murder everyone in hope of finding the bad bad witches, or track them by witchcraft scents since they'd be leaving loads somewhere.

[Rubberduckbandit]

Why the ***** is this thread still going from such a retarded idea?

[Dallane]

Why the ***** is this thread still going from such a retarded idea?

Good question.

[Mr_Bellflower]

Or become a priest, never kill anything, and build a church with mindless drones that come in every Sunday to pay you off for voo-doo-woo-doo holyness.

My favorite is playing as the Catholic church and killing all the protestants. :3
God damn heathens they be!

[Silent_Bob]

While I personally would love to see more supernatural creatures, perhaps even more types of playable supernatural creatures (Skin Walkers, for instance, were the Native American equivalent to European witches), all things supernatural should in my opinion fit with the lore of the period. People were jumping in fear of anything that went bump in the night back then; the anxiety of it fueled imaginations and led to the Salem Witch Trials in the first place. The supernatural was not something be sought, but to be mistrusted and even fought against. Of course, you can't just make every pilgrim roleplay that they fear the supernatural even if said supernatural creatures weren't really that harmful (such as a good witch), thus, unfortunately, the only other option is that supernatural creatures must have to remain evil or do evil things in order for the fear to be kept. There can be no such thing as a witch who doesn't occasionally have to harm people in order for the atmosphere to stay as it is. I wouldn't be surprised if JC added some feature making it so that the very, even passive existence of witches themselves could mean bad news bear to everyone else if they aren't hunted down.

TLDR: the only good witch is a dead one .

[alloin]

I'm a good witch ! sometimes :)

[Toorimakun]

a good witch is the witch that curses and kills the PKers.

[Lallaith]

Why the ***** is this thread still going from such a retarded idea?

Good question.

[Todryk]

Dont know if there is but think it would be cool if you could choose to be good or evil witch everything else would stay the same but have good spells and bad ones which we already have

Witches draw their power directly from Satan, so there are no good witches and they all will be utterly crushed by the Lord faithful servants. Sooner or later.