Splash damage from stone hedge to Plank fence

[Nephilim]

I made a mistake making stone wall near my plank. Had to destroy stone segment - no dmg to plank at all.
Did happen 2 days ago.

[MagicManICT]

Unless someone can clearly confirm this is bugged, I think there's enough statements saying everything works as intended. Thread closed. PM something showing the bug and I'll reopen it.

Just got a PM from another player with a couple of videos demonstrating this, so opening this back up.

[Kandarim]

the other player is now posting his videos to back this up:

video 1
video 2

Since I was replacing that piece of wall anyway, I continued destroying the old, simple, fence. Only segments directly adjacent to the plank fence splashed onto it. Even one tile between the two nullified any splash.

[Judaism]

the other player is now posting his videos to back this up:

video 1
video 2

Since I was replacing that piece of wall anyway, I continued destroying the old, simple, fence. Only segments directly adjacent to the plank fence splashed onto it. Even one tile between the two nullified any splash.

Sorry, on Plymouth this isn't occuring.

Triple checked and made a video to confirm this.

This must be an old video/other server.

My video: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=x__zziTKdus

[Snowpig]

This not correct. I have had the occurence on Plym around end of last week.

One question: did you hit the stone hedge from inside of your claim or from outside?

In my case the me and the stone hedge i destroyed were inside my pclaim.

[Kandarim]

This not correct. I have had the occurence on Plym around end of last week.

One question: did you hit the stone hedge from inside of your claim or from outside?

In my case the me and the stone hedge i destroyed were inside my pclaim.

my walls were town claimed, without a player claim. Possible it only occurs when the simple fence is placed in the extension of the plank fence? Note that your situation is different from mine in at least two aspects: the wall is not situated in the extension, and you used stone fence instead of simple fence.

[Judaism]

This not correct. I have had the occurence on Plym around end of last week.

One question: did you hit the stone hedge from inside of your claim or from outside?

In my case the me and the stone hedge i destroyed were inside my pclaim.

my walls were town claimed, without a player claim. Possible it only occurs when the simple fence is placed in the extension of the plank fence? Note that your situation is different from mine in at least two aspects: the wall is not situated in the extension, and you used stone fence instead of simple fence.

Noticed can be the issue.

The wall was destroyed inside the pclaim, and vclaim

[k545836]

I say remove this abusive buggy splash thing for good. You nerfed the walls, if you think it is still too strong - nerf it again.

BTW how makeshift fence is an exception? Can you splash damage it? I can see that it does not take splash damage from itself...

[martinuzz]

I don't see how makeshift damaging plankfence would be an intentional exception. As far as I understand, it's an oversight, and needs fixing. If that extends to stonewall damaging plank now as well, yeah, please fix this with highest possible priority.

[Snowpig]

ok, i did another run - this time the plank fence did not get any splash damage from destroying stone hedge.

observation:

If your toon is destroying the stone hedge staying outside of your claim, no splash damage to plank fence occurs.
If your toon is destroying the stone hedge staying inside of your claim, plank fence is damaged (~ 71%)