Smoked meats need a nerf

[Ukhata]

IMO all the nerf it needs is changing the group debuff to something like 30% chance for -10%.

That won't be enough - it will still allow you to glutton with no debuff at low biles

getting a new char from 5 to 30 is fine for an established player imho

[Thor]

oh come on, i've had 18 going and there's people much more insane than me
But yes, i've argued it before: they're overpowered and badly need a nerf.

Oh not you too !

[Hose]

why is everyone flaming about smoked meats? when dumplings and gourds were still overpowered as ***** nobody flamed

[ericbomb]

why is everyone flaming about smoked meats? when dumplings and gourds were still overpowered as ***** nobody flamed

John already said he's nerfing them, we're mostly just goofing around now XD the fact that everybody has dozens of meat smokers now is probably more then enough evidence for john that they're too strong.

[JohnCarver]

They served the roll for an establish base/player to 'boost' a char. Arguably the 'boost' went too far. They are getting nerfed, maybe it will be enough, maybe it won't. But with the new inheritance system the need to give that little boost is now less.

[KruskDaMangled]

They served the roll for an establish base/player to 'boost' a char. Arguably the 'boost' went too far. They are getting nerfed, maybe it will be enough, maybe it won't. But with the new inheritance system the need to give that little boost is now less.

Do you feel inclined to disclose how much of a nerf? "Club it over the head as a food and leave it bleeding and dying?" "slight nerf", what?

[Scilly_guy]

What about the ability to smoke steaks as well as cuts and to use smoked meat in recipes. This widens the range of the values the food gives (and perhaps slightly raises the average). I realise this is a lot more work than just changing the values of the food, but it makes things a lot more interesting and avoids "clubbing it over the head" (but of course it needs a good clubbing too).

[Judaism]

What about the ability to smoke steaks as well as cuts and to use smoked meat in recipes. This widens the range of the values the food gives (and perhaps slightly raises the average). I realise this is a lot more work than just changing the values of the food, but it makes things a lot more interesting and avoids "clubbing it over the head" (but of course it needs a good clubbing too).

I would even smoke slabs if it would be even slightly better.

[DarkNacht]

What about the ability to smoke steaks as well as cuts and to use smoked meat in recipes. This widens the range of the values the food gives (and perhaps slightly raises the average). I realise this is a lot more work than just changing the values of the food, but it makes things a lot more interesting and avoids "clubbing it over the head" (but of course it needs a good clubbing too).

I would even smoke slabs if it would be even slightly better.

They should just let us smoke whole animals.

[Judaism]

What about the ability to smoke steaks as well as cuts and to use smoked meat in recipes. This widens the range of the values the food gives (and perhaps slightly raises the average). I realise this is a lot more work than just changing the values of the food, but it makes things a lot more interesting and avoids "clubbing it over the head" (but of course it needs a good clubbing too).

I would even smoke slabs if it would be even slightly better.

They should just let us smoke whole animals.

No because the butchering skills will be useless then.