Page 7 of 8

Re: important PSA (public salem announcement)

PostPosted: Mon May 01, 2017 4:41 am
by Darwoth
if claims were destructable under a tbf and literally all of the other issues were left unfixed you would discover giant pclaims going out of style quite quickly after the first couple were popped and all the silver that went into them was lost.

Re: important PSA (public salem announcement)

PostPosted: Mon May 01, 2017 6:06 am
by Lazun123
Darwoth wrote:if claims were destructable under a tbf and literally all of the other issues were left unfixed you would discover giant pclaims going out of style quite quickly after the first couple were popped and all the silver that went into them was lost.


If the person had a TB protecting his Pclaim, you would need a 24hr notice to attack just to get to the Pclaim, in such time the defender could just fill the pclaim with silver to prevent destruction. Only way I see to counter that is to allow a TBF to destroy pclaims. Or nurf how much drain claims do >_<. Out of everything that is what I believe is broken!

Re: important PSA (public salem announcement)

PostPosted: Mon May 01, 2017 7:41 am
by Heffernan
Image

seems like Darwoth started his work ¦]

Re: important PSA (public salem announcement)

PostPosted: Mon May 01, 2017 7:45 am
by Darwoth
Lazun123 wrote:
If the person had a TB protecting his Pclaim, you would need a 24hr notice to attack just to get to the Pclaim, in such time the defender could just fill the pclaim with silver to prevent destruction. Only way I see to counter that is to allow a TBF to destroy pclaims. Or nurf how much drain claims do >_<. Out of everything that is what I believe is broken!


your not understanding the nature of the issue, the problem is not normal sized pclaims that are enclosed by a town. the problem is massive pclaims that engulf the entire town, these are the claims the the owners can rarely afford the upkeep on and as such when they ran dry anything on the claim becomes vulnerable including the town areas that sit on the claim without a tbf/scents.

in addition to that ANY claim stone would be destructable under a tbf whether paid or not.

Re: important PSA (public salem announcement)

PostPosted: Mon May 01, 2017 9:19 am
by JohnSnow
But what will the defenders receive instead of huge pclaims? Because personal claims seems only option for balance of sieges now. Both the defender and the attacker must invest approximately equal efforts. But construction of town costs a incrediable amount of time and resources. These are thousands bars of steel and wrought iron, hundreds thousands of bricks, boards and leather, months of labor. And what do you need to break this all? Just one character about 1500-2000 biles, which can be done in a couple of months. Also construction of towns with each patch is becoming more and more complicated, and the creation of characters is simpler and easier.

Re: important PSA (public salem announcement)

PostPosted: Mon May 01, 2017 9:33 am
by MaxPlanck
A defender of a big pclaim gets a huge claim that needs to be destroyed at the center rather then slowly chipped away via boundary stones of a town?

If a place was townclaim only and got sieged, the one doing the sieging can take over parts of the town for themselves and reduce the ability of production on the town.

Re: important PSA (public salem announcement)

PostPosted: Mon May 01, 2017 9:34 am
by Dallane
JohnSnow wrote:But what will the defenders receive instead of huge pclaims? Because personal claims seems only option for balance of sieges now. Both the defender and the attacker must invest approximately equal efforts. But construction of town costs a incrediable amount of time and resources. These are thousands bars of steel and wrought iron, hundreds thousands of bricks, boards and leather, months of labor. And what do you need to break this all? Just one character about 1500-2000 biles, which can be done in a couple of months. Also construction of towns with each patch is becoming more and more complicated, and the creation of characters is simpler and easier.


I dunno why you keep posting about mechanics when you have no clue wtf you are saying.

Re: important PSA (public salem announcement)

PostPosted: Mon May 01, 2017 9:46 am
by Heffernan
Dallane wrote:
JohnSnow wrote:But what will the defenders receive instead of huge pclaims? Because personal claims seems only option for balance of sieges now. Both the defender and the attacker must invest approximately equal efforts. But construction of town costs a incrediable amount of time and resources. These are thousands bars of steel and wrought iron, hundreds thousands of bricks, boards and leather, months of labor. And what do you need to break this all? Just one character about 1500-2000 biles, which can be done in a couple of months. Also construction of towns with each patch is becoming more and more complicated, and the creation of characters is simpler and easier.


I dunno why you keep posting about mechanics when you have no clue wtf you are saying.


Image

Re: important PSA (public salem announcement)

PostPosted: Mon May 01, 2017 9:53 am
by JohnSnow
Dallane wrote:I dunno why you keep posting about mechanics when you have no clue wtf you are saying.

More specific, please. I built towns and I know how long it takes, I did the characters and I know how long it takes too. Which of the things I wrote is not true?

Re: important PSA (public salem announcement)

PostPosted: Mon May 01, 2017 9:59 am
by Darwoth
if john snow is dodo from the days of coonman all of his posts and his claeyt level lack of a clue in all things suddenly makes perfect sense.