i still think the common earthworm should have counted giving the black friday event (I think?) where JC put up a ton of expensive items and the only accepted currency was common earthworms
That said, I also had dross (I considered it 'incomplete' because its complete form would have been a bar of metal) and I actually had a darkenbear eye as my main guess for 'nothing tangible but sight', as the light source technically give light and not sight
The darkenbear eye gives sight in the salem mechanics - although I was pretty sure it was wrong given how evil it would have been to ask people to have one of those lying around.
MarpTarpton wrote:Dross doesn't count because it's not "incomplete". When you have dross, it's done - a complete byproduct.
by that reasoning, an eggshell does not count either.
Then again, a fun event and I'm glad we got it